Show summary Hide summary
If you buy bacon for breakfasts, BLTs or to finish a salad, a lot has changed in grocery aisles?and the differences matter on the plate. In a blind tasting of 10 widely available supermarket brands, one stood out for balanced flavor and texture, while another earned praise for bold smoke and crisp edges.
The short answer
We baked 10 common bacon brands and sampled them blind to find what performs best across cooking styles. The top pick delivered a satisfying meat-to-fat ratio and reliable chew; the runner-up leaned into pronounced smokiness and crispness.
Hot toddy finds fiery upgrade in a surprising pantry staple
Team USA hockey goalie turns Caesar salad obsession into Instagram phenomenon
The criteria
Texture, not novelty, decided most scores. Testers looked for an appealing range within a single slice?a tender lean bite with rendered but not brittle fat. Super-crunchy shards were generally less popular than strips that offered both chew and crisp edges.
Flavor expectations were simple: pork first, smoke as seasoning, and only modest sweetness when present. Overly heavy smoke or cloying maple/brown-sugar notes could tip a sample away from broad usefulness.
Top picks
| Rank | Brand | Notable traits | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Winner | Smithfield Naturally Hickory Smoked ? Thick Cut | Even balance of lean and fat; retains chew when baked; balanced salt and smoke | Everyday cooking: breakfast, sandwiches, salads |
| Runner-up | North Country Smokehouse Organic Applewood ? Uncured | Pronounced, complex smoke with a touch of sweetness; extra-crisp edges | When you want an assertive smoke flavor |
Why the winner worked
The top-ranked bacon stood out for keeping a meaty presence after roasting. Its slices were labeled thick-cut, which helped prevent the strips from turning into brittle fragments in the oven. Tasters described the overall seasoning as smoky but natural, allowing the pork flavor to remain the star.
Why the runner-up stands out
This bacon turned up the smoke dial: deeper, tobacco-like notes paired with a subtle sweetness. That profile divided opinions?some loved the amplified smoke and crisp texture, while others found the sweetness slightly distracting. If you favor a clear smokehouse character, this is the more adventurous choice.
The full list of brands we tested
- 365 by Whole Foods ? Uncured Applewood Smoked
- Applegate ? Natural Hickory Smoked, Uncured
- Boar’s Head ? Naturally Smoked
- Jimmy Dean ? Premium Hickory Smoked
- Oscar Mayer ? Naturally Hardwood Smoked
- Nature’s Promise ? Hickory Smoked (Stop & Shop)
- North Country Smokehouse ? Organic Applewood (Uncured)
- Smithfield ? Naturally Hickory Smoked Thick Cut
- True Story Foods ? Applewood Smoked Kurobata
- Wellshire Farms ? Uncured
Key takeaways
Texture mattered more than marketing claims. In our set, slices with greater width held up better during baking: they rendered fat without turning into thin, glasslike flakes. Those qualities made bacon more versatile across dishes.
Label language around curing can be misleading. Products marketed as “uncured” typically use natural sources of nitrate?commonly celery powder?which convert to nitrites during processing. The functional chemistry is the same: nitrites slow microbial growth, contribute cured color, and influence flavor. Nutrition experts warn that “uncured” does not necessarily mean “nitrate-free.”
Sweeteners and added flavorings were acceptable when subtle, but the most-liked samples tasted principally of pork and smoke rather than syrup, fruit extracts, or overpowering spices.
Who should buy what
- Everyday cooks: Choose a balanced, thick-cut option that holds texture when cooked.
- Smoke lovers: Pick a product with pronounced applewood or hickory notes; expect crisper edges and stronger taste.
- Label-conscious shoppers: Read ingredient lists?”no nitrates/nitrites added” often refers only to synthetic sources; natural nitrates may still be present.
How we tested
We conducted a blind tasting of 10 widely available supermarket brands. Each bacon was baked on foil-lined sheet pans at 400?F to ensure even cooking and to let slices render in their own fat. Samples were presented in randomized order to multiple tasters to reduce palate fatigue and bias.
Panelists scored texture, flavor balance, smoke intensity, and overall appeal on standardized tasting sheets. Results were tallied without editorial influence to produce the rankings above.
Practical note: if you cook bacon frequently, trying a few different cuts and cooking methods?pan-frying, oven-roasting, or broiling?can change how a brand performs. Thickness and smoke level are the two attributes most likely to alter whether a bacon becomes a weeknight staple or a specialty treat.
Candy-bar stuffed cookies spark lines at viral pop-up
Pantry essential boosts oatmeal, smoothies and pie crusts: why home cooks stock it
