Show summary Hide summary
Before you signal for a “dirty” martini this weekend, take a moment to check the garnish. A longtime bar owner and mixologist warns that olives — often kept in jars of salty liquid — can show signs of poor handling or storage that matter to your health and your night out.
Why the olive on your skewer deserves a second look
Persian dinner pop-up arrives in Dupont Circle: reservations open
Breakfast sandwiches for hectic mornings and slow weekends: quick recipes to make today
Justin Lavenue, a master mixologist and co-owner of a well-known Austin bar, says olives are commonly preserved in brine, but that solution is not a catch-all safety measure. Exposure to warm temperatures, oxygen, or contamination from utensils and hands can degrade olives over time and, in rare cases, create conditions that increase the risk of foodborne illness.
That doesn’t mean every martini olive is dangerous — but it does mean garnishes deserve the same attention you would give any other ready-to-eat food. Lavenue emphasizes practical observation over panic: look for simple signs that indicate proper care rather than assuming the jar is fine.
What to inspect — quickly
- Good signs:
- Olives that are plump, firm and have a clean, salty taste.
- Clear, bright brine and containers that appear recently washed.
- Garnishes kept covered, chilled, and handled with tongs or clean tools.
- Red flags:
- Cloudy or discolored brine, or olives that look dried out or feel slimy.
- Garnish trays left open at room temperature, or new olives dumped on top of old without rotation.
- Utensils buried in the jar, flies around the garnish station, or staff touching garnishes with bare hands after handling cash or menus.
These cues are quick to spot at the bar and tell you more than the label on a jar. If something looks off, trust that first impression.
Read the room — and the bartender
Beyond the jar, the condition of the bar itself is revealing. Sticky surfaces, unclean speed rails, or a visibly neglected ice well can signal broader hygiene lapses. Conversely, a bartop wiped regularly and neatly stored bottles usually means the staff pays attention to details.
Watch how garnishes are handled. If the person making your drink reaches for olives with bare fingers after touching money or menus, ask for tongs or request the drink without the garnish. A brief question is reasonable and often appreciated by conscientious staff.
Simple steps to protect your drink
- Ask for garnishes to come from a covered container or for the bartender to use tongs.
- If you’re unsure, decline the olive and order your martini neat or with a lemon twist instead.
- When in doubt, pick a different venue — or choose a sealed bottled drink.
Food-safety issues with olives are uncommon, but visible signs of neglect are easy to spot and worth acting on. A small check before you sip can keep your cocktail from becoming an unpleasant story.
87-pound weight loss after daily workouts sparked by retired Taco Bell item
Schlitz 1950s beer tasting: rare formula delivers surprising vintage flavor
